Presence & Absence: Carlo Scarpa, Querini Stampalia, & Water

July 23rd, 2009 § 4

Where is ground level after all, where is terra firma? Hard to tell. Instead there is a strange sensation of hovering in a zone of water and sky as the earth drifts somewhere in the mix.  – Michael Cadwell

[all references and images are taken from Cadwell, Michael.  Strange Details.  Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2007.]

The Querini Stampalia Foundation by Carlo Scarpa is a powerful reminder of architecture’s capacity to embody particular qualities without necessarily being literal.  Querini Stampalia was originally a family palace built in Venice during the 16th that was converted into a small foundation devoted to “promote study of useful disciplines and nation and foreign knowledge” (12).  After a series of damaging floods in the early 1900’s, Carlo Scarpa was commissioned to renovate the ground floor in anticipation of future flooding.

exterior of the Querini Stampalia Foundation

exterior of the Querini Stampalia Foundation

What’s exiting in this work is Scarpa’s understanding of water as an unsettling force – as a medium caught between the solidity of the earth and the volatility of the sky.  Water is at once dependable and volatile – it is present like the earth, but in constant flux like the sky.  And as Cadwell points out, Venice embodies this precariousness.  “In Venice, buildings do not spring from the earth – they tether themselves to the mud below, or they hover above it” (8-9).  This aquatic quality, this precariousness, pervades Querini Stampalia through details that unsettle and keep us on edge.

Ground Floor Plan

ground floor plan

For instance, the main entrance to Querini Stampalia is a small footbridge leading from the adjacent campiello directly into the ground floor foyer.  Seemingly simple, the bridge is slightly eccentric so that the entrance to Querini Stampalia lies slightly below the campiello.  So even before entering the building, Scarpa calls into question the solidity of the ground that is so precarious in Venice.  The bridge drops us below the established ground line and brings us closer to the water below.

entrance bridge

entrance bridge

Inside the main gallery, we find a similar articulation of conflicting levels and an unsettling ambiguity regarding the location of water and ground.  First, the gallery steps down from the entrance foyer, bringing the floor even further below the ground line outside.  There are three columns in the space, but none of them align to establish a firm ground line.  Finally, the floor is detailed for floods and wraps up the sides of the wall to define a waterline.  Without being explicit, Scarpa places the visitor somewhere beneath the water, but where exactly is unclear. “So we are up to our ankles.  The grass outside [in the courtyard] is above this line, but no matter, the water rises to our shins” (25).  These waterlines all undermine any sense of a solid ground, but instead locate the room somewhere between the ebb of the tide.  And though the gallery anticipates water and its presence can be felt throughout, the most unsettling part is the lack water and the lack of any reference to establish where that waterline actually lies.  The gallery gives hints and suggests possibilities but provides no assurance.  Instead it lies somewhere in the middle.  Water is absent, but its presence is felt throughout.

Main Gallery Looking Towards Garden

Main Gallery Looking Towards Garden

conflicting levels within the gallery

conflicting levels within the gallery

Tagged: , , , , , , ,

§ 4 Responses to “Presence & Absence: Carlo Scarpa, Querini Stampalia, & Water”

  • marven niffi says:

    I like your post so much, Its very best and informative .

  • Cat Bauer says:

    I have quoted part of your piece on my blog, Venetian Cat – The Venice Blog. I have taken the liberty of correcting the word “exiting” in your post to “exciting,” as I believe it is a typo.

    Here is the direct link:

    http://venetiancat.blogspot.com/2010/11/new-flash-querini-stampali-wins.html

  • redtube says:

    unwillingly pregnancy could not obtain double in some of the underlying problems at the appropriate time and with adequate frequency for the lack of or applied the wrong method as very ordinary reasons olabilir.kadin any month pregnant probabilities of 20-25% is . Couple due to the lack of information they can reduce this possibility by certain behaviors . In some couples who were infertile simple precautions to be taken and procedures to be applied very easily get pregnant without any treatment with

  • There are hundreds of people who are unaware of their credit
    scores and they get rejected by the lenders due to
    their weak credit history. That’s why credit report monitoring has
    become such an essential safeguard against identity theft and other
    attacks. Get your credit report and credit score now and check for any errors, discrepancy, identity theft or bad credit.

  • § Leave a Reply

What's this?

You are currently reading Presence & Absence: Carlo Scarpa, Querini Stampalia, & Water at 3SIXØ Architecture BLOG.

meta

Bad Behavior has blocked 294 access attempts in the last 7 days.